The South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation has existed since 1985, yet it remains one of the least integrated regional blocs in the world. Intra-regional trade within South Asia sits at barely 5% of total trade, compared to roughly 25% within ASEAN. The gap is striking for a region that shares deep historical, cultural, and economic ties. So the real question is not whether SAARC matters, but how it can be made to actually deliver. The answer lies in three interlinked areas: trade, connectivity, and a shared regional identity, backed by lessons from initiatives that have genuinely worked on the ground.
Table of Contents
- Why SAARC underperforms
- Fixing trade: making SAFTA work
- Reducing the sensitive lists
- Tackling non-tariff barriers
- Moving towards deeper integration
- Building connectivity across borders
- The connectivity agreements that stalled
- The case for sub-regional cooperation: BBIN
- Building a shared regional identity
- The promise and limits of the visa scheme
- Public diplomacy and cultural exchange
- Learning from initiatives that worked
- The Grameen Bank model
- The SEWA model
- Putting it together: a realistic roadmap
Why SAARC underperforms
Before fixing something, it helps to understand why it stalls. SAARC operates on consensus, meaning every member must agree before any major decision moves forward. In theory this protects smaller states from being overruled. In practice, it lets a single member veto progress for everyone. Bilateral tensions, particularly between India and Pakistan, have repeatedly stalled summits and blocked key agreements.
The structural problems do not end there. Poor physical connectivity, weak institutions, and a long list of trade barriers keep the region fragmented. A useful starting point is to treat SAARC’s weaknesses not as one big political problem, but as several practical ones that can each be tackled.
Fixing trade: making SAFTA work
The South Asian Free Trade Area, or SAFTA, came into force in 2006 with the goal of reducing tariffs across the region and moving towards deeper economic integration. On paper it is ambitious. In reality, its results have been modest. The reasons are well documented, and so are the fixes.
Reducing the sensitive lists
Sensitive lists are sets of products that member countries exclude from tariff concessions to protect their domestic industries. The problem is that these lists are often too long and cover exactly the goods that smaller economies could profitably export. Research on Nepal’s trade with India found that many products with high export potential were placed on the sensitive list, leaving little for least-developed members to gain from SAFTA. The SAFTA agreement itself requires that the sensitive list be reviewed every four years with a view to reducing it. Speeding up and deepening these reductions would directly expand intra-regional trade.
Tackling non-tariff barriers
Lowering tariffs alone is not enough. Non-tariff barriers such as complex customs procedures, technical standards, and bureaucratic delays often restrict trade more than tariffs do. SAFTA already grants special treatment to least-developed members through smaller sensitive lists and more relaxed rules of origin, but the everyday friction at borders undercuts these benefits. Harmonising product standards, simplifying customs paperwork, and investing in faster clearance systems would make the existing agreement far more effective without needing any new treaty.
Moving towards deeper integration
The longer-term vision is more ambitious. At the 2014 Kathmandu Summit, member states renewed their commitment to a South Asian Economic Union, to be achieved in phases through a free trade area, a customs union, a common market, and eventually a monetary union. Achieving even the early phases of this would require full implementation of SAFTA, finalising the agreement on trade in services, and protecting cross-border investment. These are realistic, incremental steps rather than grand leaps.
Building connectivity across borders
A free trade pact means little if goods and people cannot move easily. South Asia suffers from weak roads, railways, and air links, which raise costs and slow down trade. Connectivity is therefore one of the most powerful levers for making cooperation real.
The connectivity agreements that stalled
At the 2014 Kathmandu Summit, India proposed a SAARC Motor Vehicles Agreement to allow the smooth movement of vehicles across borders. It could not be signed due to reservations from Pakistan. A proposed SAARC Regional Railways Agreement met the same fate. These were not minor schemes; they were exactly the kind of practical projects that would have turned cooperation into something citizens could feel.
The case for sub-regional cooperation: BBIN
When the full group cannot move forward, willing members can. After the motor vehicles agreement stalled, Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, and Nepal signed the BBIN Motor Vehicles Agreement in 2015. This sub-regional pact aims to allow seamless movement of passenger, personal, and cargo vehicles among the four countries.
BBIN matters for two reasons. First, it directly benefits landlocked Bhutan and Nepal by improving their access to seaports through India and Bangladesh. Second, it offers a model: when a large multilateral forum is blocked, smaller groups of willing partners can keep cooperation alive. This does not legally replace SAARC, but it does shift the centre of gravity of regional cooperation towards groups that can actually act. The lesson for SAARC is that progress need not always be all-or-nothing; flexible, sub-regional arrangements can build momentum that the wider group may later join.
Building a shared regional identity
Trade and roads address the economics. But lasting cooperation also needs people who feel connected to one another. This is where people-to-people ties and public diplomacy come in. Right now, South Asia has some of the most restrictive visa regimes in the world, which keeps ordinary citizens apart.
The promise and limits of the visa scheme
SAARC did try to ease this. The SAARC Visa Exemption Scheme was launched in 1992 to encourage people-to-people contact. The catch is its narrow scope. It covers only 24 categories of people, such as dignitaries, judges, parliamentarians, businesspersons, journalists, and sportspersons, rather than ordinary tourists or students. As Prime Minister Narendra Modi observed at the 2014 summit, it is harder to travel within the SAARC region than to reach Bangkok or Singapore. Widening the scheme to include students, academics, and tourists would do far more to build a sense of shared belonging.
Public diplomacy and cultural exchange
A regional identity grows through contact. More student exchanges, joint cultural events, shared media, and academic collaboration can slowly build trust that survives political ups and downs. The point of public diplomacy here is not propaganda but familiarity: when citizens of different countries study, trade, and travel together, the region starts to feel like a community rather than a collection of rivals.
Learning from initiatives that worked
One of the strongest arguments for optimism is that South Asia has already produced development models that the rest of the world has copied. SAARC does not need to invent solutions from scratch; it needs to scale up what already works.
The Grameen Bank model
The Grameen Bank in Bangladesh, founded by Muhammad Yunus, pioneered microfinance by lending tiny sums to poor borrowers, especially women, and achieved repayment rates as high as 98%. Its success in turning credit access into poverty reduction earned it a Nobel Peace Prize in 2006 and inspired similar programmes across the world. The lesson for SAARC is that a regional approach to financial inclusion, built on proven local models, could lift millions out of poverty across member states.
The SEWA model
In India, the Self-Employed Women’s Association has spent over five decades organising poor self-employed women in the informal economy into cooperatives for credit, healthcare, childcare, and market access. Its model of building collective bargaining power has been replicated across the region and beyond. Notably, SEWA Bank and Grameen Bank are widely recognised as pioneers of microfinance in South Asia, with a strong emphasis on social development rather than profit alone. These are home-grown success stories that a more effective SAARC could turn into shared regional programmes for women’s empowerment and informal-sector livelihoods.
Putting it together: a realistic roadmap
Making SAARC more effective does not require a dramatic overhaul. It requires steady, practical work on several fronts at once. On trade, this means fully implementing SAFTA, cutting sensitive lists faster, and dismantling non-tariff barriers. On connectivity, it means reviving stalled transport and rail agreements while using flexible sub-regional groupings like BBIN to maintain momentum. On identity, it means broadening the visa scheme and expanding people-to-people exchange. And across all of these, it means scaling up the development models, from microfinance to women’s cooperatives, that the region has already proven can work.
The biggest obstacle remains political: the consensus rule that lets bilateral disputes paralyse the entire group. Until that changes, sub-regional cooperation will likely carry much of the load. But the direction is clear. A region this connected by history and culture has every reason to be connected by trade and trust as well.
What do you think? Should SAARC reform its consensus-based decision-making so that bilateral disputes can no longer block region-wide progress? And is the rise of sub-regional groups like BBIN a sign that SAARC is slowly being replaced, or a practical way to keep regional cooperation alive?
References
- https://www.orfonline.org/research/saarc-vs-bimstec-the-search-for-the-ideal-platform-for-regional-cooperation
- https://ideas.repec.org/p/pra/mprapa/37893.html
- https://wits.worldbank.org/GPTAD/PDF/archive/SAFTA.pdf
- https://www.un.org/ldcportal/content/south-asian-free-trade-area-safta
- https://www.saarc-sec.org/index.php/areas-of-cooperation/economic-trade-and-finance
- https://www.pib.gov.in/newsite/PrintRelease.aspx?relid=122417®=3&lang=2
- https://www.drishtiias.com/daily-news-analysis/bbin-motor-vehicles-agreement
- https://www.saarc-sec.org/index.php/about-saarc/saarc-visa-exemption-scheme
- https://www.nyulawglobal.org/globalex/saarc1.html
- https://cprindia.org/journalarticles/saarc-visa-a-case-for-regional-integration-analysis/
- https://borgenproject.org/grameen-bank/
- https://www.sewa.org/about-us/
- https://www.spotlightnepal.com/2025/12/06/microfinance-and-gender-transformation-moving-access-agency/
Leave a Reply