India hosts one of the largest and most diverse refugee populations in the world, yet it has no single law that defines who a refugee is or what protections they deserve. People fleeing Chinese rule in Tibet, civil war in Sri Lanka, military persecution in Myanmar, and unrest in Afghanistan have all found shelter here. But once they arrive, they enter a legal grey zone. Their treatment depends less on a clear set of rights and more on diplomacy, politics, and the discretion of officials. This piece breaks down how the law actually treats refugees, why different groups receive vastly different treatment, and what the gap between policy and reality means for the people caught in it.

Table of Contents

No refugee law, only foreigner law

The most important thing to understand is that the word “refugee” has no formal meaning in Indian statutes. India is not a signatory to the 1951 UN Refugee Convention or its 1967 Protocol, and it has never passed a domestic refugee law despite drafts like the Model National Law on Refugees being proposed over the years. As a result, judicial rulings and executive orders form the backbone of how refugees are handled.

For decades, refugees were treated under the same laws that govern any foreign national. Chief among these was the Foreigners Act, 1946, a colonial-era law that simply defined a “foreigner” as a person who is not a citizen of India. It made no distinction between a tourist who overstayed a visa and a family fleeing genocide. Alongside it sat the Passport (Entry into India) Act, 1920, the Registration of Foreigners Act, 1939, and the Immigration (Carriers’ Liability) Act, 2000.

The 2025 overhaul

This framework changed significantly in 2025. The Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025 came into force on 1 September 2025, consolidating and repealing all four older laws into a single statute. The new law sets up a Bureau of Immigration, mandates registration of foreigners on arrival, and introduces tougher penalties, including jail terms for using forged travel documents.

Crucially, though, the new law did not fix the core problem. It still does not define or recognise “refugees” as a distinct category. A person fleeing persecution remains, in the eyes of the law, just a foreigner whose entry and stay the central government can regulate or terminate. The 2025 Act actually expands government discretion, with critics from human rights organisations arguing that it grants sweeping, unchecked powers over who can enter and remain.

Constitutional protections that do apply

Even without a refugee law, refugees are not entirely without rights. The Constitution extends certain fundamental rights to all persons, not just citizens. Article 21, which guarantees the right to life and personal liberty, applies to foreigners too. Courts have used this to argue that the State cannot deprive even a non-citizen of life or liberty without a procedure established by law.

However, the right to reside and settle in India under Article 19 is reserved only for citizens. This is the central tension in nearly every refugee case: refugees can claim the right to life, but not the right to stay. The government has repeatedly used this distinction to justify deportation while still acknowledging basic humanitarian protections. The result is a system that protects refugees inconsistently, often depending on which court hears the case and what the political climate happens to be.

Tibetans: the most secure, but still not citizens

Tibetan refugees arrived after the Dalai Lama fled Chinese rule in 1959, and they enjoy arguably the most stable position of any refugee group. More than 80,000 Tibetans initially sought refuge, and the community has been allowed to build settlements, schools, and even its own administrative body, the Central Tibetan Administration.

Registration Certificates and Identity Certificates

Tibetans are documented through two key papers. The Registration Certificate (RC) is a stay permit that allows them to live and travel within India. The RC must be periodically renewed, with the renewal period lengthened from one year to five years for those born in India or resident for over twenty years. Importantly, the RC is short for “registration certificate,” not “refugee certificate,” and as the Tibetan Legal Association notes, it does not confer a legal right to reside; renewal remains at the discretion of authorities.

For international travel, RC holders can obtain an Identity Certificate (IC), often called the “Yellow Book.” It resembles an Indian passport, complete with the Ashoka pillar on a yellow cover, but is not accepted as a travel document by many countries. Obtaining one can take months or even years, frequently arriving after the planned travel dates have passed.

The 2014 Tibetan Rehabilitation Policy attempted to standardise welfare across states, but it explicitly noted that schemes like the National Food Security Act apply only to Indian citizens. A 2013 court ruling did open a path to citizenship for Tibetans born in India between 1950 and 1987, but most Tibetans remain in a privileged-yet-precarious limbo: settled, documented, but not citizens.

Sri Lankan Tamils: decades in camps

Sri Lankan Tamils fled the island’s civil war in waves, beginning around 1983 and intensifying during the conflict’s peak in the late 2000s. Over 300,000 Sri Lankan Tamils entered India across these waves. According to the Ministry of Home Affairs Annual Report for 2023-24, more than 57,000 still live in refugee camps, mostly in Tamil Nadu, with roughly 33,000 living outside camps.

Life inside the camps

Camp residents face significant restrictions on their movement. Those in camps generally cannot leave Tamil Nadu and need permission even to travel out of their district, while those living outside must report periodically to the police. Surveillance tightened sharply after the 1991 assassination of Rajiv Gandhi, which was linked to the LTTE.

The deeper tragedy here is generational. A camp is meant to be temporary, yet for many Sri Lankan Tamils it has stretched across three to four decades. Researchers describe these refugees as living in limbo, belonging neither to Sri Lanka nor to India. Thousands were born in Indian camps, studied in Indian schools, and speak with local accents, yet they cannot vote or hold secure title to property. Their condition has been described as a form of structural statelessness.

Politically, the issue carries weight in Tamil Nadu. The state government has renamed the camps as “rehabilitation camps” and announced housing improvements. Notably, the 2019 Citizenship Amendment Act excluded Sri Lankan Tamils from its fast-track naturalisation route, even as it offered a path to certain other migrants.

The Bangladeshi immigration question

No refugee-related issue is more politically charged than that of migrants from Bangladesh. The debate is complicated because it blurs the line between refugees fleeing hardship and economic migrants crossing a porous border. Many who came are not classified as refugees at all but as “illegal immigrants,” and the topic feeds directly into anxieties about demographic change, employment, and electoral politics in states like Assam and West Bengal.

The Citizenship Act, 1955 contains a special provision, Section 6A, dealing with persons who came to Assam from Bangladesh, though it is not specifically about refugees. Exercises like the National Register of Citizens (NRC) in Assam attempted to identify who could prove citizenship, leaving many people anxious about being declared foreigners. The placement of someone in the “illegal immigrant” category rather than the “refugee” one carries enormous consequences, since it strips away even the limited goodwill extended to recognised refugee communities.

Rohingya: resistance and deportation

The Rohingya, a Muslim minority fleeing persecution in Myanmar, represent the sharpest example of India’s ad hoc and increasingly restrictive approach. The government has consistently refused to recognise them as refugees, treating them instead as illegal immigrants and security risks.

The Supreme Court’s handling of Rohingya cases illustrates the limits of legal protection. In 2021, the court declined to halt the deportation of around 170 Rohingya detained in Jammu, holding that the right to settle in India belongs only to citizens. In 2025, the court reiterated that if Rohingya are found to be foreigners under Indian law, they must be deported, and remarked that UNHCR identity cards may offer them no protection under domestic law.

The human cost has been severe. Hundreds of Rohingya have been detained in immigration centres, many without ongoing court cases, facing harsh conditions and minimal legal aid. In 2025, rights groups documented expulsions of Rohingya, including some registered with the UN refugee agency. The Supreme Court has framed the central question it must answer: are the Rohingya refugees or illegal entrants, and what rights follow from that classification?

Why treatment varies so widely

Reading these cases together, a pattern emerges. The level of protection a refugee group receives in India correlates less with the severity of persecution they fled and more with factors like diplomatic relations, religious and ethnic affinity with local populations, and domestic political utility. Tibetans benefit from longstanding sympathy and the moral authority of the Dalai Lama. Sri Lankan Tamils draw support from a powerful regional identity in Tamil Nadu. The Rohingya, lacking both a domestic constituency and favourable geopolitics, find themselves at the receiving end of the harshest treatment.

This selectivity is precisely what a dedicated refugee law would constrain. Without uniform criteria, decisions remain discretionary and inconsistent. A clear statute defining refugee status, laying out fair determination procedures, and codifying the principle of non-refoulement (not returning people to places where they face danger) would replace ad hoc politics with predictable rights. For now, the absence of such a law leaves hundreds of thousands of people dependent on shifting executive will and the occasional intervention of the courts.

What do you think? Should India enact a comprehensive refugee law that applies uniformly to all groups, or does its case-by-case approach give it useful flexibility in a complex neighbourhood? And if a single law were created, how should it balance humanitarian obligations against the genuine security and resource concerns that the government raises?

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

References
  1. https://www.lloydlawcollege.edu.in/blog/understanding-refugee-law-in-india.html
  2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreigners_Act,_1946
  3. https://prsindia.org/billtrack/the-immigration-and-foreigners-bill-2025
  4. https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/research/2025/11/india-immigration-and-foreigners-exemption-order-threatens-human-rights/
  5. https://www.tibetjustice.org/?p=724
  6. https://tibetanlegalassociation.org/en/legal-overview-of-the-status-of-tibetans-in-india/
  7. https://www.refworld.org/docid/556825a44.html
  8. https://sabrangindia.in/from-permanent-refuge-to-perpetual-limbo-why-sri-lankan-tamil-refugees-remain-without-citizenship-even-as-electoral-assurances-reshape-belonging-in-bengal/
  9. https://www.fmreview.org/return/valcarcelsilvela/
  10. https://cplan.in/stateless-inside-sri-lankan-tamils-and-indias-refugee-gap/
  11. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/4/9/supreme-court-has-signed-our-death-warrant-rohingya-in-india
  12. https://www.refugeesinternational.org/reports-briefs/a-lifetime-in-detention-rohingya-refugees-in-india/
  13. https://www.hrw.org/news/2025/08/28/india-scores-of-rohingya-refugees-expelled

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Global Politics

1 Understanding Globalization

  1. Meaning and Features of Globalisation
  2. Phases of Globalisation
  3. Types of Globalisation
  4. Digital Globalisation
  5. Theories of Globalisation
  6. Globalisation and Sovereignty
  7. Criticism

2 State Sovereignty and Jurisdiction

  1. Sovereignty
  2. Jurisdiction
  3. Globalisation
  4. Effects of Globalisation
  5. Globalisation and Economic Sovereignty
  6. Globalisation and Political Sovereignty
  7. Globalisation and Cultural Sovereignty
  8. Jurisdiction in a Globalized World

3 Global Economy and Financial Architecture

  1. Age of Mercantilism (1500-1750)
  2. Industrial Revolution
  3. Global Economy and Trade until 1945
  4. Antecedents and the Ideology of Neoliberalism
  5. Liberalism
  6. Neoliberalism
  7. International Monetary Fund (IMF)
  8. International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD)

4 Global Trading System (WTO and Others)

  1. World Trade Organization (WTO)
  2. General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT)
  3. Uruguay Round, 1986-1993
  4. Doha Round
  5. WTO Principles, Functions and Mechanisms
  6. GATT, WTO and the Developing World
  7. WTO and India
  8. Crisis of the Liberal International Economic Order (LIEO)

5 Working of MNCs and TNCs

  1. Concept and Characteristics of MNCs and TNCs
  2. Evolution of TNCs and the Global Economy
  3. TNCs in the Global Economy
  4. Relationship of TNCs with the Home and the Host Countries

6 Globalization-Cultural and Technological Dimensions

  1. Globalisation
  2. Culture
  3. Cultural Dimension of Globalisation
  4. Technical Dimension of Globalisation
  5. Impact of Globalisation on Culture with Technological Development

7 Global Politics and Environment

  1. Economic Development and Environmental Challenges
  2. Environmental Conservation and the United Nations
  3. Global Institutions for Environmental Protection
  4. Issues of Concern
  5. Right to Environmental Security
  6. Paris Climate Agreement
  7. India and the Paris Climate Commitments

8 Challenges of Proliferation of Weapons of Mass Destruction

  1. Weapons of Mass Destruction (WMDs)
  2. Biological Weapons
  3. Chemical Weapons
  4. Nuclear Weapons
  5. International Non-Proliferation Regime
  6. Partial Test Ban Treaty (PTBT)
  7. Fissile Material Cut-Off Treaty (FMCT)
  8. The Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT)
  9. Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty (CTBT)
  10. Challenges and the Road Ahead

9 Non-Traditional Security Threats

  1. Non-Traditional Security: Concept and Content
  2. Post-Cold War Non-Traditional Security Threats
  3. Terrorism as Non-Traditional Security Threat
  4. International Terrorism
  5. US’ Global War on Terrorism
  6. Threat of Terrorism: Case of India
  7. Militancy and Separatism in Jammu and Kashmir
  8. Islamist Terrorism
  9. Insurgency in North-East India
  10. Khalistan Militancy in Punjab
  11. Naxalite Movement

10 Refugees and Migration

  1. Conceptual Analysis of Migration and Refugees
  2. Political Economy of Migration
  3. Global Trends in Migration and Refugee Movement
  4. Geography of Global Migration
  5. Resettlement and Return of Refugees
  6. India’s Perception and Response to Refugee Problem
  7. India’s Approach towards International Conventions on Refugees
  8. Status of Refugees in India

11 Human Security

  1. Defining Human Security: UNDP Definition
  2. Security as a State/National Concept
  3. Shift to ‘People-centred’ Concept
  4. Human Security, Human Rights and Human Development
  5. Modern Concept of Human Security
  6. Varied Dimensions of Human Security
  7. Human Security and Traditional Security

12 Global Resistances (Global Social Movements and NGOs)

  1. Global Resistance
  2. Underlying Theoretical Formulations
  3. Resisting Globalisation
  4. Global Social Movements
  5. Social Movements and NGOs

13 Alternative Perspectives on Globalization

  1. Understanding Globalisation
  2. Phases of Globalisation
  3. Theoretical Explanations of Globalisation
  4. Types of Globalists
  5. Adverse Impact of Globalisation
  6. Alternatives to Globalisation